Hi Guys, Here are some screenshots from our new coming soon game Following the comments from @jerry and @Christoph Here are the revised icon choices -
Hey Eyal, Here is something that I would recommend you do. 1. Do a search in app store of games that are of a similar type as yours 2. Take a screen capture of that screen filled with icons. 3. In photoshop or other design software, stick your icon in overtop of one of the icons that is on the screen. Then the question for you to ask yourself is, does my icon stand out from the others? If not what needs to change to make it stand out. I would say that your icon samples are too complex. Simplify, Simplify, Simplify.
I completely agree with jerry. They are too complex. Even though they do represent well the game which is also very complex visually speaking. I definitely would go with number 3, even though if you can simplify the background a little more or put it more backwards so the character stands out even more I would go with that. Check your icons here: http://www.appsparky.com/app-icon-test-upload-icon You will see that the character of number 1, 2, 4 and 5 are too small to stand out. Also, the tip by jerry is awesome as well. Appsparky can't provide you with similar games.